I had dogs, rabbits, monkeys, goldfishes, birds, and one cat.
One night, I came home from the bar. Angry and drunk I used a pocket knife and cut Pluto's eye out. I then put him out of its misery and hung him.
One night when I was at the bar, there was this black cat with a white circle on it's chest. I decided to take it home when I found out it loved me.
The next day, I found out that the new cat had one eye. I decided to take it to the cellar and chop it's head off when my wife stopped my arm. I then turn the axe to my wife and lodged it into her head. I then hide the body.
On the fourth day, the cops came to my house. Everything seem normal till I bang the part of the wall where I hid the body. A muffled scream came from behind the wall. Officers ran and took apart the wall. What they found was the body, and the cat with a bloody mouth and fire in his one eye.