Antonio starts to question his thought and faith to his religion after everything that has happened. In his dream his "God"questions him if he is loyal or why a town drunk should be forgiven if he has sinned
His dreams turns into a nightmare when the witch sisters appear for revenge. They torture Tony by having his brothers chained up and hunt his family and Ultima to show that even she could not help.
The ashes of Tony's family is buried so that they would be reborn in the holy land of their families ancestors. They would be given another chance, this chance is given by the golden carp that didn't die. In the end the golden carp is becoming more of a God than Tony's Catholic God.