Actually yes. My theory is called the split community.
Interesting. Tell me more
Well first of all I believe they split up for a higher chance for survival. What I think happened is 15 fit onto the pinnacle and went to Chesapeake Bay while the rest went to Croatan with Manteo
Why would you think that?
Well first of all the pinnacle that was left with the colonists was gone. The colonists also had a plan to travel to Chesapeake but there captain denied at first. Finally the colonists carved Croatan into a tree but left no cross signifying danger.