Bronwyn calls the Bayview four together and they go over the information that all of them have found or heard. They discuss how the four of them could be related to Simon and what could have prompted someone to kill him.
Bronwyn watches the news channel Mikhail Powers show a 4chan comment that Simon made about a school shooting, where the shooter shot himself afterward. He wrote that if the boy wanted to kill himself, he could have been more creative than just shooting the people he hated.
The police, in an effort to make it look like they are doing something, arrest Nate for Simon's murder because he has a reputation of being a drug dealer.
After another meeting with Bronwyn and Cooper, Addy puts pieces together and realizes that Jake has been writing and posting the Tumblr posts all along.
With Cooper's help, Bronwyn tracks down the license plate of one of the crashed cars from when they were in detention with Simon and discovers that Simon himself paid the drivers to crash their cars in front of the school.
Bronwyn, Addy, Addy's sister Ashton, Cooper, and Cooper's boyfriend Kris meet at a coffee shop to compare all the notes that they made about the investigation and to discuss who could have killed Simon. They whittle all of the information down until Kris makes a point about how Simon could have been depressed and killed himself.