Annabelle and her brothers were just going to school for a normal day. When Annabelle noticed there was a new student. And she doesn't seem very friendly.
The new student Betty has hurt Annabelle and her brothers. Annabells brother was just walking home from school and suddenly he got cut on the face by a wire that someone set up.
Annabella's friend Ruth got hit in the eye with a rock, and they didn't know who did it, but Annabelle thought it was Betty. Betty blamed it on Toby and everyone believed it. After Betty was blamed for hitting Ruth in the eye with a rock, all of a sudden she goes missing. People started saying that Toby did something to Betty.
Everyone starts to blame Toby for Betty's disappearence. But Annabelle knows that Toby is inoccence and conviences him to hide in the loft of the barn. Annabelle decides to completly change Toby's apperence so that he wouldn't be recognizable. Annabelle remebers hearing something near Toby's house and there is a well that Betty could have fell down. Annabelle tells her dad and everyone goes to ceck it out, including Toby.
They get to the well and figure out that Betty is stuck on a pipe in the well. Someone had to go down and help Betty escape,and Toby volunteered to go and save her. Toby is the hero and no one has relized that it is Toby. Betty had a pipe impaled in her shoulder and had to be rushed to the hospital.
Sadley Betty didn't make it and passed away. And not long after Toby also passed away. Toby left hiding in the barn and was hiding under a bridge. The police saw him with two guns and shot him. Although the two guns did not work, he left his working one behind.