The narrator had always liked the old man, and the old man had never wronged him, but the only problem was the old man's eye! His eye was like a vultures eye! Every time the narrator saw the old man's eye, he got chills. So, the narrator decided to try and get rid of the old man, when he's sleeping.
While the old man was sleeping, the narrator crept into the old mans room, and watched him sleep for awhile. The narrator siad he couldn't kill the old man while he was sleeping because his eye was completely shut.
The narrator decided to take a step into the old mans room, but the old man woke up to hearing someone step into his room. The old man couldn't see the narrator because it was pitch black. The narrator opened up his lantern and shined it on the old mans vulture like eye, and could hear the old mans heartbeat.
HE'S BENEATH YOU!!! I KILLED HIM!!!
The narrator went crazy after seeing the old mans eye. So, he threw the old man on the floor, grabbed a blanket, and started to suffocate the him. Afterwards, the old man just laid there limp, dead.
After he suffocated the old man he started to take all his body parts. After he was done taking the old mans body parts apart, he needed to dispose of the body. So, the narrator took of some off the floorboards from the floor, and disposed of the old mans body there.
The narrator heard a knock at the door, so he went to go open it. When he opened the door he saw the police was here, and he got all nervous. The police told him that they got a complaint about some screaming. The narrator told them that it was him waking up from a bad dream. The narrator offered them some tea in the old mans room. So, while they were having tea, the narrator thought he would get away with murder, but he heard a pounding sound from under him. And right away he knew it was the old mans heart. The narrator went crazy and finally gave himself away to the police.