In this story, a pretty, popular girl named Joelynn falls in love with a boy who's under her league named Henry.
The problem is, Henry thinks that Joelynn is narcissistic and rude, and she gets a rude awakening when she finds out her feelings for Henry aren't mutual.
Joelynn, obviously upset by the news, goes straight home after school instead of her usual hanging out with her friends. She ends up going to sleep and having a dream about Henry.
In the dream, it's just Joelynn and Henry in a classroom. All that's happening is Henry is standing in the middle of the room, smiling. Joelynn ends up becoming fascinated with his teeth, and even fawns over them in her dream.
When Joelynn wakes up, her room is different. It has scratch marks on the walls, makeup is scattered, and a little box with Henry's name and exactly 5 hearts lining each side is shining in her closet.
When Joelynn opened the box, 32 bloody, messy teeth were inside.