Mr.White makes his second to last wish and he wishes for Herbert to come back. Mr and Mrs White hear knocking and Mrs. White thinks it is Herbert. Mrs. White wants to open the door but Mr. White wont let her.
Mr.White is shocked that his wish came true. The knocking continues and Mr. White still doesn't let Mrs.White open the door. Mrs.White keeps begging because Mr.White shouldn't be afraid of his son
Mr. White makes his last wish. The knocking stops and they are both confused on what is going on. Mr. White finally tells Mrs. White what is going on d he told her that he wished for Herbert to go back to his grave. Mrs White was mad at him for the rest of the night.