The old mans eye, that's the only thing that had bothered Poe.
After going in the old mans room every night, still Poe acted like nothing happened and greeted the old man with a smile ever morning.
One night like all the others when Poe would go in the old mans room, the old man had awoken
The old man woke up by the sound and stood by the foot of his bed listening to see if he could hear, asking "whos there?" Poe came and smuggled the old man.
Poe covered up all the evidence so it looked like nothing had happened at all. Then there was a knock at the door, it was the cops and they came, Poe greeted them kindly. They talked adn everyone was calm.
Poe's head got to the best of him, he was thinking about it and thinking about it until he gave up and told the cops everything, where the body was and how it all went down