We got lot's of food from our adventures. How bout' a feast?
The Virginia Company planned to start an English colony, search for gold, and find a new trade route to Asia.
Many of the settlers in Jamestown died of starvation, and the settlers who came to Jamestown did not have any building skills, farming skills, or trading skills.
I would teach the settlers how to hunt, farm, etc. Then, I'd announce we'll have a special feast and use the food we got from farming, hunting, etc. After that, they would keep the leftovers from the feast.