On April 26, 1587 there was John White and 117 colonists who began the journey in the new world. There goal was to establish a new colony close to Chesapeake Bay. One of the colonists that went was John Whites daughter who was expecting a baby.
A month later after they got back, on August 18, 1587 John Whites daughter gave birth to a baby girl. They named her Virginia. Virginia was the first English kid born in North America.
I believe scenario four would be the most likely to happen. I think that it would most likely happen because they found a body in the house. I also think that because you can't lie about seeing pieces of a body in the house. They were also very violent.