There was a man and his wife who lived with a cat, a monkey, a gold fish, and a quiet dog.
The husband was not himself lately, he started drinking and became more aggressive. it got to the point where any little thing annoyed him and in this case it was the his black cat. so that night he cut out the cats eye because it pissed him off that the cat was scared of him.
later that night he couldn't take his cat being scared of him anymore so when the cat wasn't looking he grabbed it from behind and hung it outside on a tree.
after he finished his job he decided he wanted to go out and drink, that's where he spotted a black cat that was identical to pluto. he asked the bartender if it was a stray. he later then took it home.
The man loved the cat and cat loved him back, but he soon got aggravated by the cat and grabbed a ax and chased the cat down to the basement, the wife stopped his husband mid way and upset his husband so instead of killing the cat his killed his wife.
he hid her body behind the fireplace where no one could find it or so he thought.