The girls discover that Dear Johnny's gravestone is broken, and they assume that he has risen from the dead and come to tell them who murdered him.
A few days later, the girls go back to the graveyard at night to put Dear Johnny to rest. While they are there, they think that they see Dear Johnny's gravestone floating towards them, but it turns out to be a new gravestone being put in place. The reason why the gravestone was broken in the first place was because the man ran over the gravestone accidentally.
Samantha goes back to the graveyard after the other girls leave and sees Crazy Pete standing at Dear Johnny's grave and it turns out that Crazy Pete is Dear Johnny's father.