I have waited 5 years to see you Daisy and this doesn't seem like its really happening.
I'm still in love with you.
I want to Jay, I really wish I could.
Leave To and come live with me Daisy, he's no good for you.
I think this is how the conversation would have gone when Daisy and Gatsby met. They hadn't seen each other in 5 years and I think it would have been sort of awkward to see each other. Especially since daisy didn't know Gatsby lived right down the road for years.