Mrs. White remembers about the monkeys paw. She tells Mr. White that he still has two wishes left and believes that it could bring back her son. Mrs. White begs and he finally agrees to do it.
Mr. White makes the wish for his son to come back. He has a bad feeling about it, but they waited to see if anything would happen. Soon after, they start to hear something coming from outside their door.
Mrs. White then starts to believe that it is her son Herbert. Mr. White does not open the door because he does not know what would be outside the door. Mrs. White thinks that he his afraid of his son, but he thinks that is is something else.