Krustofski is operating his show as usual, but Tyler notices the crazed anger Sideshow Robert is in, just staring at Krustofski like he let his dog on Robert's lawn. Tyler was worried Sideshow Robert would plot something too unsettling to imagine.
The security camera footage shows Krustofski apparently threatening and robbing the well-respected owner of the Stop 'N Shop, Mohammad. Tyler notes the size difference between Krustofski and Sideshow Robert's shoes.
Tyler learns about the horrible news when he gets home from school, watching it on the TV. He felt out of sorts, knowing that his beloved entertainer was no more, while his parents tried to calm him down.
Krustofski is arrested and summoned to the Court, where there was no hope in Krustofski not being guilty. As Tyler's father was there, he was a witness, and when asked who he saw, Tyler pleaded his dad not to say it was him, but still said it.
Sideshow Robert gives 2 tickets for him and his sister. He went up on-stage to talk about Krustofski, as Sideshow Robert tries to be sincere yet continue on. When saying "big shoes to fill", Tyler notices he has big feet, and it was him all along.
Sideshow Robert is caught by Chief Williams outside along with the other officers, after they saw Tyler showing the proof live on TV. As the people crowd, Sideshow Roberts swears revenge at Tyler, and he looks up at Robert in shock and disappointment.