Evan is called to the principal's office for unknown reason. When he comes in, he sees Connor's parents (Larry and Cynthia). Connor's parents think that Connor wrote that letter to Evan when really, Evan wrote that letter for his therapist but Connor stole his letter when he saw his sister's name in the letter (Zoe). Evan tried to tell them that He wrote the letter not Connor, but Cynthia notices Evan's cast which says "Connor" on there when Evan ran into Connor in the computer lab before Connor stole Evan's letter.
Evan Is suddenly called to the office for an unknown reason.
Why does Mr.Howard want to see me today?
"You're Evan right? We're Connor's parents"
"This is from Conner. Conner never mentioned you. But then we saw 'Dear Evan Hansen.'"
"We didn't think Connor had any friends, But this note, it seems to suggest pretty clearly that you and Connor were friends."
"It's okay. You can open it. It's addressed to you. Conner wrote this to you."
"I mean, it's right there: 'Dear Evan Hansen'."
This is my letter that Connor stole!
"What does he mean Larry?"
"Calm down Cynthia."
"Conner didn't write this... I'm sorry, I should probably leave."
"Larry look! Connor's name is on his cast! His 'best and most dearest friend'!"