As Mr. and Mrs. White and Herbert playing chess while waiting for their guess in the Parlor of Laburnam villa on a cold and rainy night.
Herbert found out about the paw and wished to keep it after many warning by Morris. After Then gave his father the paw to so he can make a wish. The day after Herbert got killed by machinery at work. The White's were given 200 pounds as compensation. Mrs.White remembers that there are 2 wishes left. Mrs.White thought it was Herbert.
They suddenly there is a knocking at the door
Mr. White searches for the paw, to make their third wish. After the knocking stops and Mrs.White opens the door to see nothing is there.
We can assume that Mr.White wished for his son to be dead again or rest in peace.
Theme: Be careful for what you wish forConflict: Man vs Supernatural