”Harrison Bergeron”, the short story penned by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. in 1961, imagines the world in 120 years, where the government has taken complete control over free thought and complete equality has finally been achieved – at a price, of course.
In the quest for true equality, people gave up their rights in favor of eliminating all competition, drive, and desire: the very things that inspire innovation and creativity. The people in charge are the only ones who are allowed to think, and that power has grave consequences for Harrison Bergeron, a 14-year-old boy who is already 7 feet tall and virtually uncontrollable. The story explores important themes, such as what total equality at the cost of individuality could look like, and the dangers of losing free thought to a tyrannical government. The dystopian world Vonnegut paints is frighteningly dull, and frighteningly realistic.
The word “utopia” was coined by Sir Thomas More for his book about an ideally organized society. It is from the Greek topos meaning “place”. The prefix is intentionally ambiguous; in Greek, the prefix ou- means “not”, while the prefix eu- means “good”. So a u-topia could either be a “good-place”, or a “not-place”, an imaginary place.
One of the oldest recorded and most widely-known utopias is the Garden of Eden. A utopia is a perfect society, where everything is ideally organized, and residents go about their lives happily.
A dystopia, on the other hand, is the complete opposite of a utopia, using the prefix dys-, from the Greek for “bad”. It is a flawed society, dys-functional and undesirable. In literature, these two terms often coincide. Many dystopias look idyllic to begin with, but over the course of the story reveal their true nature, which is typically sinister and flawed.
Check out our article on Dystopian Literature and the six common dystopian elements you and your students can track throughout the story!
An important distinction to note before beginning “Harrison Bergeron” is that the handicaps given to the characters are not the same as being handicapped. The word “handicapped” that students will be most familiar with is similar in a way, because each indicates an obstacle that alters the abilities of the person affected. The handicaps given to characters in the story are meant to hinder them in some way in order to make them equal to others. Some of the handicaps they are assigned include:
Create an interactive classroom debate to help students actively process the complex ideas in “Harrison Bergeron”. Debates encourage critical thinking and respectful discussion, making abstract themes more relatable.
Select a prompt such as, “Should society prioritize equality over individuality?” or “Is total equality truly possible or desirable?” to spark student interest and link directly to the story’s themes.
Divide students into two teams and go over the debate format. Set clear time limits for arguments and rebuttals. Emphasize respectful listening and evidence-based responses to ensure a positive experience.
Ask students to support their points with specific examples from “Harrison Bergeron” and real-world scenarios. This strengthens their arguments and deepens understanding of equality and individuality.
Wrap up by discussing what students learned and how their views may have changed. Highlight respectful disagreement and insight as key takeaways. Use exit tickets or a quick write to capture final thoughts.
The main message of 'Harrison Bergeron' is a warning about the dangers of enforced equality through government control, highlighting how suppressing individuality and free thought can lead to a loss of creativity and personal freedom.
Teachers can introduce dystopia by explaining how 'Harrison Bergeron' depicts a flawed society where extreme measures are taken to ensure equality, using examples from the story such as handicaps and limited freedoms to spark discussion and critical thinking.
Easy activities include analyzing character handicaps, debating the pros and cons of equality vs. individuality, creating storyboards of dystopian elements, and discussing essential questions about freedom and conformity.
In the story, 'handicap' refers to artificial limitations imposed to make everyone equal, while 'handicapped' typically means having a physical or mental disability. Vonnegut uses handicaps as metaphors for forced conformity, not actual disabilities.
Individuality is crucial in 'Harrison Bergeron' as it represents personal freedom and creativity. Students can explore this theme by discussing how characters are affected by losing their unique traits and analyzing the consequences of a society where everyone is forced to be the same.