This storyboard model assumes that students have already learned the conjugations of ser and estar and their differences of use. It also assumes that students have already done some basic practice and are ready to put it all together. The creative scene is also appropriate to provide differentiation for advanced students.
Have students create their own creative scene, targeting images that will require various uses of ser and estar. Students will then write a descriptive paragraph below the cell, using complete sentences and describing all aspects of the illustration.
For example, this sample storyboard provides opportunities to express the location, physical attributes, and identities of objects and people. It also provides examples of personality, emotion, nationality, profession, material of an object, possession, time of day, and date. This scene also provides the opportunity to review basic vocabulary and expressing likes, dislikes, and pastimes should the teacher choose to interlace topics further.
Advanced: Instead of students writing out the description below the cell, students can instead give an oral presentation of the description.
(These instructions are completely customizable. After clicking "Copy Activity", update the instructions on the Edit Tab of the assignment.)
Check understanding in real time by using exit tickets or mini whiteboard responses at the end of a lesson. This helps you spot which students need more practice distinguishing ser and estar.
Give students sentence starters that require filling in with either ser or estar. This scaffolds their thinking and encourages correct verb selection in context.
Pair students up and have them quiz each other using flashcards or quick oral prompts. Explaining their choices reinforces learning and builds confidence.
Display photos or illustrations and ask students to describe them using ser or estar. Visual cues make grammar more memorable and meaningful.
Correct mistakes positively and highlight when students use ser or estar correctly. Positive reinforcement boosts motivation and helps students internalize the rules.
A creative scene activity for ser vs. estar involves students creating visual storyboards or illustrations that require the use of both verbs. Students describe each scene using complete sentences, applying ser and estar for context like identity, location, emotion, and profession, helping reinforce their correct usage in authentic scenarios.
Use visual prompts and creative scenes where students must describe people, places, and objects using both ser and estar. Encourage them to focus on permanent traits (ser) versus temporary states or locations (estar), and provide feedback on their sentence choices.
Examples include: La chica es inteligente (personality), El libro está en la mesa (location), Hoy es lunes (date), Estoy cansado (emotion). Use scenes to prompt students to create similar sentences covering identity, location, emotions, and time.
Challenge advanced students with oral presentations describing their creative scenes, or require more complex vocabulary and nuanced sentences. Let them interlace other topics like likes/dislikes, pastimes, or cultural comparisons for deeper understanding.
Incorporate collaborative storyboard creation, role-playing, or digital tools where students illustrate and describe scenes. Adding competitive or creative elements motivates students and reinforces correct verb usage in a fun, memorable way.