Perhaps the most difficult part of atomic structure to grasp is the current understanding of how electrons are arranged outside the nucleus. Students generally come to chemistry comfortable with the idea of electrons orbiting the nucleus like planets around a sun. Though this idea has been known to be incorrect for nearly 100 years, it persists due to the ease at which people can relate to it. It's helpful to use an analogy to help students understand that electrons move about in three-dimensional space, arranged by increasing potential energy and described by clouds of probability.
In this activity, students will create a visual representation of electron energy levels. The example provided above uses the analogy of a hotel with multiple floors. Students can work with this analogy, or come up with their own. This is a great way to shift students away from the imperfect solar system model into something complicated but more accurate.
Electrons with the least potential energy are found near the nucleus. As the distance between the nucleus and the electrons increases, the potential energy also increases. Where students might be tempted to talk about “rings” of electrons, electrons are actually arranged into energy levels and sublevels. The sublevels are sets of orbitals, clouds of space that predict the 90% chance of locating the electron. These probability clouds are determined mathematically.
Though not a perfect analogy, this can be likened to an electron hotel. The floors of the hotel would represent energy levels, each one farther away from the ground floor, or nucleus. Each floor would have wings that are sublevels and within the wings are rooms, or orbitals. A room may contain 0, 1, or 2 electrons. The hotel would populate the rooms, wings, and floors in order of increasing energy, just as the Aufbau Principle describes the build-up of electrons according to energy.
(These instructions are completely customizable. After clicking "Copy Activity", update the instructions on the Edit Tab of the assignment.)
Student Instructions
Create a visual representation of electron energy levels using a hotel analogy. Each floor is an energy level, with the ground floor being the nucleus.
Make abstract concepts concrete by using familiar classroom items to represent energy levels, sublevels, and orbitals, helping students visualize electron arrangement in a hands-on way.
Use colored blocks, stackable cups, or boxes to represent hotel floors (energy levels), with smaller containers or envelopes for wings and rooms. Label each clearly to reinforce terminology and make it easy for students to follow.
Let students use tokens, beads, or sticky notes as electrons. Have them 'check in' to the rooms (boxes/cups) following the same Aufbau Principle, mimicking how electrons fill energy levels in atoms.
Challenge students to place 'electrons' in the correct sequence, starting from the lowest energy level and moving up. Ask guiding questions about why certain 'rooms' fill first to encourage critical thinking.
Lead students in comparing their hotel model to real electron configurations. Highlight the limitations and strengths of the analogy, and encourage students to reflect on how this hands-on activity deepened their understanding.
The electron hotel analogy compares electrons' arrangement around the nucleus to floors, wings, and rooms in a hotel: floors represent energy levels, wings are sublevels, and rooms are orbitals. This helps students visualize how electrons fill up energy levels based on increasing energy, instead of orbiting like planets.
To teach electron energy levels with a hotel analogy, describe each floor as a different energy level, wings as sublevels, and rooms as orbitals. Students can create charts or drawings showing electrons filling rooms in order, emphasizing that lower floors are closer to the nucleus and electrons fill from the ground up.
The solar system model is inaccurate because electrons do not orbit the nucleus in fixed paths. Instead, they occupy probability clouds or orbitals defined by energy levels and sublevels, with their locations described mathematically rather than as clear, circular orbits.
The Aufbau Principle states that electrons fill orbitals starting from the lowest available energy level before moving to higher ones. In the hotel analogy, this means electrons fill the lowest floors and rooms first, building up according to energy.
Students often incorrectly imagine electrons as orbiting like planets, or refer to 'rings' instead of energy levels and sublevels. Using analogies like the electron hotel helps correct these misconceptions by showing electrons occupy specific energy levels and orbitals.