In this activity students will compare and contrast three possible pets and identify the pros and cons of each one. This example compares: dogs, small birds, and monkeys.
| Dogs | Dogs require great effort, time, and money; there are many rewards to having a dog, but owner must be responsible and serious about owning one. |
|---|---|
| Birds | Birds are a good first pet; they are small, like to cuddle, and are cheaper than dogs, but they do require time for play and cleaning. |
| Monkeys | Birds are dangerous and very expensive; they may carry diseases and are often taken illegally from the wild. |
(These instructions are completely customizable. After clicking "Copy Activity", update the instructions on the Edit Tab of the assignment.)
Student Instructions
Engage students by dividing them into small groups and assigning each group a pet to advocate for. Have each group prepare arguments using the pros and cons discussed in the compare/contrast activity. This approach encourages critical thinking and teamwork while helping students practice persuasive speaking skills in a fun, interactive way.
Establish guidelines for respectful discussion and assign roles such as speaker, note-taker, and timekeeper to each group. Clear roles help keep the debate organized and ensure every student participates. This structure fosters a positive learning environment and builds confidence in public speaking.
Give students time to gather facts, list arguments, and plan their presentations. Encourage them to use both the article content and their own experiences or additional research. This preparation supports deeper understanding and helps students make well-informed points during the debate.
Moderate the debate by letting each group present their case and respond to others. Prompt students to listen carefully and ask thoughtful questions. This practice develops communication skills and respectful discussion habits.
Lead a class discussion after the debate to reflect on what was learned and how these skills apply to decision-making in daily life. Ask students to consider how comparing pros and cons can help with other choices. This step reinforces critical thinking and personal responsibility.
A straightforward method is to create a chart with columns for each pet (like dogs, birds, monkeys), then list pros and cons under each. Students can visually compare features such as cost, care, safety, and companionship to help make informed decisions.
Encourage students to research or discuss each pet’s responsibilities, expenses, and risks. Use guided questions or a worksheet to help them list benefits (like loyalty or low cost) and drawbacks (such as danger or high maintenance) for each animal.
Examples include making a Venn diagram, writing short essays, or using storyboards to illustrate the differences and similarities among pets. Students can also debate which pet would make the best class companion.
Understanding pros and cons teaches students critical thinking and responsible decision-making. It helps them weigh benefits versus challenges, leading to more thoughtful choices about pet ownership.
Dogs require more time, effort, and money but offer loyalty. Birds are cheaper and cuddly but still need care. Monkeys can be dangerous, expensive, and may carry diseases, making them a poor choice for most people.