Abbey and Noah sneak out to the Coral Queen to spy on Dusty Muleman and to try and find evidence to prove that their father was right about the raw sewage being dumped in the bay. While this was happening a bald man puts his hands around Abbey's neck and she bites him to try and defend herself. Both Noah and Abbey quickly ride their bikes home after this incident occurs. Donna Underwood, their mother never realizes that they sneak out and everything goes back to normal.
The front cover of the daily newspaper is about Noah's dad, Paine Underwood sinking the Coral Queen. After this Noah goes to visit his father in jail. After hearing the discussion between his mom and Mr.Shine about getting a divorce, Noah goes into further discussion with his dad about the subject.
Mr.Shine had been taking a lot of time and he still hadn't came to pick up the fishing skiff. Mr.Shine was very late so Noah went to his house to get him. Later, Noah talks to Shelly. Noah thinks that Shelly might be able to help them with their plan.