Students will create storyboards that imagine the loss of the Bill of Rights in society. This is a creative activity for students that will allow them to see the harsh reality of life without freedoms. Students should choose any three freedoms from the Bill of Rights and represent how different their society would be without them. For each representation, students will write a description of their scenario in the space below each image.
Life without the 1st Amendment
In this scenario, the police are arresting the priest for practicing his religion. Under the 1st Amendment in the Bill of Rights, each citizen has the right to practice any religion they desire.
Life without the 3rd Amendment
By the 3rd Amendment, the government cannot quarter, or house, soldiers in the private homes of citizens, without permission. In this scenario, a man is coming home to a house full of soldiers.
Life without the 8th Amendment
In this scenario, a man is found guilty of petty theft and is being punished by eating his weight in candy or being executed. In the 8th amendment, the courts cannot enforce "cruel or unusual punishment" on a guilty party.
Extended Activity
To extend this activity, students can take the activity above to a more personal level. Students can create a storyboard that represents how their lives would be different without the Bill of Rights. Students should use examples of their day-to-day life and show what they would no longer be able to do or how their lives would be changed after the loss of the freedoms in the Bill of Rights.
(These instructions are completely customizable. After clicking "Copy Activity", update the instructions on the Edit Tab of the assignment.)
Student Instructions
Create examples of what life might be like without 3 of the amendments in The Bill of Rights.
Encourage students to share their ideas and responses to the storyboard activity by posing open-ended questions. Active listening and respectful dialogue help students explore diverse perspectives.
Arrange students in groups of 3–5 to promote participation. Smaller groups allow everyone to contribute and build confidence before sharing with the whole class.
Designate roles like facilitator, note-taker, and timekeeper to ensure equal involvement and keep the discussion focused on the Bill of Rights.
Present brief, relatable situations where rights might be challenged. Ask students how they would feel or respond, encouraging empathy and critical thinking.
Bring groups together to share main points from their discussions. Highlight the importance of each right and the impact of losing them.
Life Without the Bill of Rights is a creative activity where students storyboard how society would change without key freedoms. Students select three amendments, depict scenarios missing those rights, and write descriptions, helping them understand the real-world impact of these freedoms.
Students can create storyboards that show what everyday life might be like without specific amendments, such as losing religious freedom, being forced to house soldiers, or facing cruel punishments. This approach encourages empathy and deeper understanding.
Without the Bill of Rights, citizens could lose the freedom to practice religion, be forced to let soldiers live in their homes, or face cruel and unusual punishment for minor crimes. These examples help students grasp the importance of each amendment.
Tell students to pick three amendments, title each storyboard panel with the amendment, illustrate how life would change without it, and write a short description under each image. Encourage creativity and real-life scenarios relevant to their daily lives.
Have students personalize the activity by showing how their own lives would be affected without these rights. Ask them to use real-life examples and reflect on freedoms they value most, fostering critical thinking and personal connection to the material.