Workplace Ethics Scenarios for Students | Ethics Dilemma Activity Skip to main content
https://www.storyboardthat.com/lesson-plans/soft-skills/workplace-ethics-dilemma
Lesson Plan Overview
Template and Class Instructions
Lesson Plan Overview Accordion Arrow

Lesson Plan Overview


The ethics problems teens face at their first jobs are rarely dramatic. They are small favors and small shortcuts: a friend asks you to clock in for them, a coworker takes a free drink, a manager tells you to skip a step. Because the stakes look low, students often have not thought them through until they are in the moment. In this activity, students storyboard a workplace dilemma: the situation, the pressure, two or three options with their likely consequences, and the choice they would make and why.

Before You Begin

  • Dilemmas to choose from: clocking in for a late friend; a coworker giving free food to friends; finding a mistake in your own paycheck that pays you more; being asked to sign off on a cleaning checklist you didn't finish.
  • Time needed: one class to storyboard, plus a class discussion.
  • Assessment: the dilemma is clear, each option has a realistic consequence for the worker, the coworker, and the business, and the final choice is defended with a reason.

Example: "Can You Clock Me In?"

CELLWHAT IT SHOWS
The situationLeo texts Maya: "Running 15 min late. Can you clock me in? Ms. Grant won't know."
Option 1: Do itLeo isn't written up today, but the cafe pays him for time he didn't work. If Ms. Grant checks the camera, both of them could lose their jobs.
Option 2: RefuseMaya says no. Leo is annoyed, but nobody's job is at risk.
Option 3: Refuse and helpMaya says no but suggests Leo text Ms. Grant now that he'll be late. He does, and she tells him thanks for the heads-up.
The choiceMaya picks Option 3: "Clocking in for him is the same as taking money from the cafe, but I can still help him."

For a general decision-making model students can reuse, see the Decision-Making Skills guide.

Differentiation

  • Grades 6–8: set the dilemma at a school job or club, such as selling snacks for a fundraiser.
  • Grades 9–12: have students find the rule in a real employee handbook (or the school's work-based learning agreement) that applies to their dilemma.

Template and Class Instructions Accordion Arrow

Template and Class Instructions

(These instructions are completely customizable. After clicking "Copy Activity", update the instructions on the Edit Tab of the assignment.)



Student Instructions

Create a storyboard that shows a workplace ethics dilemma and your decision.

  1. Click "Use This Template" from the assignment.
  2. In the first cell, show the dilemma: what happens and who is asking you to do what.
  3. In the next cells, show two or three options and the likely consequence of each.
  4. In the last cell, show the choice you would make.
  5. In the descriptions, explain how each option affects you, your coworkers, and the business, and why you made your choice.
  6. Save and submit your storyboard.

Lesson Plan Reference


Lesson Plan Overview


The ethics problems teens face at their first jobs are rarely dramatic. They are small favors and small shortcuts: a friend asks you to clock in for them, a coworker takes a free drink, a manager tells you to skip a step. Because the stakes look low, students often have not thought them through until they are in the moment. In this activity, students storyboard a workplace dilemma: the situation, the pressure, two or three options with their likely consequences, and the choice they would make and why.

Before You Begin

  • Dilemmas to choose from: clocking in for a late friend; a coworker giving free food to friends; finding a mistake in your own paycheck that pays you more; being asked to sign off on a cleaning checklist you didn't finish.
  • Time needed: one class to storyboard, plus a class discussion.
  • Assessment: the dilemma is clear, each option has a realistic consequence for the worker, the coworker, and the business, and the final choice is defended with a reason.

Example: "Can You Clock Me In?"

CELLWHAT IT SHOWS
The situationLeo texts Maya: "Running 15 min late. Can you clock me in? Ms. Grant won't know."
Option 1: Do itLeo isn't written up today, but the cafe pays him for time he didn't work. If Ms. Grant checks the camera, both of them could lose their jobs.
Option 2: RefuseMaya says no. Leo is annoyed, but nobody's job is at risk.
Option 3: Refuse and helpMaya says no but suggests Leo text Ms. Grant now that he'll be late. He does, and she tells him thanks for the heads-up.
The choiceMaya picks Option 3: "Clocking in for him is the same as taking money from the cafe, but I can still help him."

For a general decision-making model students can reuse, see the Decision-Making Skills guide.

Differentiation

  • Grades 6–8: set the dilemma at a school job or club, such as selling snacks for a fundraiser.
  • Grades 9–12: have students find the rule in a real employee handbook (or the school's work-based learning agreement) that applies to their dilemma.

Template and Class Instructions

(These instructions are completely customizable. After clicking "Copy Activity", update the instructions on the Edit Tab of the assignment.)



Student Instructions

Create a storyboard that shows a workplace ethics dilemma and your decision.

  1. Click "Use This Template" from the assignment.
  2. In the first cell, show the dilemma: what happens and who is asking you to do what.
  3. In the next cells, show two or three options and the likely consequence of each.
  4. In the last cell, show the choice you would make.
  5. In the descriptions, explain how each option affects you, your coworkers, and the business, and why you made your choice.
  6. Save and submit your storyboard.

Lesson Plan Reference


How to Teach Workplace Ethics with a Dilemma Storyboard

1

Present a small dilemma

Share a realistic first-job situation, such as Leo texting Maya to clock him in because he is running late.

2

Brainstorm the options

As a class, list two or three things the worker could do, including one that solves the problem honestly.

3

Trace the consequences

Students show the likely result of each option for the worker, the coworker, and the business.

4

Make and defend a choice

In the last cell, students show what they would do and explain why.

5

Discuss the choices

Compare students' decisions and connect them to a real employee handbook or work-based learning agreement.

Frequently Asked Questions about Teaching Workplace Ethics

What workplace ethics scenarios work best for teens?

Small, realistic ones: clocking in for a late friend, a coworker giving free food to friends, a paycheck error in your favor, or signing off on a cleaning checklist you didn't finish. These feel low-stakes, which is exactly why teens are unprepared for them. Skip dramatic cases like embezzlement; students need to rehearse the favors and shortcuts they will actually face.

How should I grade the ethics dilemma storyboard?

Give 2 points for a clear dilemma; 3 points per option, 1 each for a realistic consequence to the worker, the coworker, and the business; and 2 points for a final choice defended with a reason. Two options make a 10-point storyboard. Grade the reasoning, not which option the student picks.

Why include a "refuse and help" option?

Students often see ethics as a choice between helping a friend and following the rules. Maya's third option, refusing to clock Leo in but suggesting he text Ms. Grant that he'll be late, shows there is usually a way to do both. Ask students to look for that kind of option in every dilemma before they choose.

How should I run the class discussion?

Have students who made different choices for the same dilemma share their final cells, then ask: Who is harmed if no one finds out? Would your answer change if Leo were your best friend? What does the cafe lose? For grades 9 to 12, have students find the matching rule in a real employee handbook or work-based learning agreement.

Can middle school students do this activity?

Yes, with a familiar setting. For grades 6 to 8, set the dilemma at a school job or club, such as selling snacks for a fundraiser when a friend asks for a free one. The structure stays the same: situation, options, consequences, choice. English learners can use the frame "If I ___, then ___ will happen."




Testimonials

“By using the product, they were so excited and they learned so much...”
–K-5 Librarian and Instructinal Technology Teacher
“I'm doing a Napoleon timeline and I'm having [students] determine whether or not Napoleon was a good guy or a bad guy or somewhere in between.”
–History and Special Ed Teacher
“Students get to be creative with Storyboard That and there's so many visuals for them to pick from... It makes it really accessible for all students in the class.”
–Third Grade Teacher
https://www.storyboardthat.com/lesson-plans/soft-skills/workplace-ethics-dilemma
© 2026 - Clever Prototypes, LLC - All rights reserved.
StoryboardThat is a trademark of Clever Prototypes, LLC, and Registered in U.S. Patent and Trademark Office